2026 Season

54% of ABS
challenges have
overturned the ump.

The ABS Challenge System lets players dispute ball-strike calls via Hawk-Eye cameras. We track every challenge — who wins them, and whether it matters.

ABS
STRIKE
0 Challenges Filed
0 Calls Overturned
0% Overturn Rate

Season at a Glance

Through November 20, 2026
0 Total Challenges
0% Overturn Rate
0 Total Overturns
0% K Rate vs. 2025

Net Run Value vs. Win %

Pearson r = -0.193 · Weak correlation

Each badge is a team. The x-axis shows how much run value they've extracted from ABS challenges; the y-axis shows their win percentage. Ringed teams are in playoff position. Click a team to highlight it.

Ringed teams are in playoff position

View as table
Team Net Run Value Win % Playoffs
CIN 10.21 0.463 —
CHC 9.16 0.549 Yes
ATH 9.16 0.395 —
DET 7.82 0.469 —
TEX 6.21 0.494 —
KC 3.95 0.426 —
AZ 3.31 0.531 —
ATL 1.85 0.580 Yes
NYY 1.83 0.578 Yes
PHI 1.60 0.543 Yes
LAD 1.18 0.617 Yes
BOS 0.61 0.537 Yes
SF 0.24 0.401 —
STL 0.20 0.475 —
COL -0.34 0.358 —
TOR -0.47 0.488 —
MIA -0.55 0.494 —
LAA -1.33 0.383 —
MIN -1.60 0.475 —
BAL -1.89 0.491 —
HOU -3.04 0.500 Yes
WSH -3.53 0.475 —
MIL -3.75 0.636 Yes
SEA -4.19 0.469 —
CLE -5.76 0.525 Yes
TB -6.19 0.605 Yes
NYM -6.44 0.457 —
SD -7.50 0.562 Yes
CWS -11.54 0.518 Yes
PIT -12.85 0.506 —

Pearson r = -0.193. The correlation is weak. So far, challenge performance does not strongly predict winning, and the line is close to flat: sitting above it mostly means winning more than average, which playoff teams do by definition. Methodology

Top Teams by Net Run Value

All 30 teams →
# Team Net RV Success% Win%
1 +10.21 61.6% .463
2 +9.16 58.9% .549
3 +9.16 60.3% .395
4 +7.82 57.4% .469
5 +6.21 58.0% .494

Top Players

Catchers by Overturn Rate

All catchers →

Min 20 challenges

# Name Rate Chall
1 81.4% 86
2 70.8% 65
3 68.8% 93
4 68.4% 136
5 68.1% 113

Batters by Overturn Rate

All batters →

Min 10 challenges

# Name Rate Chall
1 68.0% 25
2 63.6% 22
3 61.3% 31
4 60.9% 23
5 60.0% 25

How to Read This Site

Net Run Value (Net RV)

The headline metric. It measures how much run value a team gains from ABS challenges compared to what's expected. Positive = extracting value. This comes directly from Baseball Savant's net_net_runs field.

Success Rate

Overturns divided by total challenges. Watch the sample size — a team with 3/5 is not meaningfully better than 40/80. We flag small samples throughout.

Correlation ≠ Causation

If challenge performance correlates with winning, that doesn't mean challenges cause wins. Better teams may simply be better at everything, including challenging. We're honest about this.

Full methodology and metric definitions →

About Challenge The Ump

MLB's 2026 ABS Challenge System is the biggest rule change in a generation. No public site was aggregating this data in a clean format and connecting it to standings. So we built one — Challenge The Ump. Fully static, fully open source, refreshed daily from Baseball Savant. No tracking, no ads. Learn more →